English_Executive_Summary_with_QR_扫描版_01
넳 넲

English_Executive_Summary

 

Executive Summary

On March 1, 2026, the Anti-Domestic Violence Law of the People’s Republic of China (the “Law”) marked ten years since it took effect. Its implementation has made clear progress over the past decade. Yet media reports show that survivors of domestic violence continue to face difficulty obtaining a divorce. To understand the barriers domestic violence survivors encounter in divorce proceedings and to support more effective implementation of the Law, Beijing Qianqian Law Firm analyzed 1,000 divorce judgments involving domestic violence allegations issued between March 1, 2016 and February 28, 2026. The study examines how the legal rules on domestic violence operate in divorce litigation and explores factors that may affect courts’ findings. Based on the results, it makes recommendations for strengthening implementation of the Law.

 

Key findings

1. Gaps in judicial reasoning between domestic violence allegations and legal findings

Whether domestic violence is established should be a central factual and legal issue that judgments must address. Yet this study found widespread deficiencies in the reasoning of divorce judgments involving domestic violence allegations.

 

In 45.30% of judgments, the plaintiff’s evidence was not clearly described, and courts often gave only brief, conclusory findings about whether evidence was accepted. This made the reasoning difficult to follow and scrutinize. Across the full sample, 399 judgments did not expressly assess whether the conduct alleged by the plaintiff constituted domestic violence. Of these, 24 confirmed that the defendant had used physical violence, such as hitting, yet did not address whether it constituted domestic violence.

 

Judgments also rarely invoked the Law itself. Only two of the 1,000 judgments expressly cited the Law, China’s dedicated law on preventing and responding to domestic violence and providing relief, and both did so to explain why the dispute between the parties did not constitute domestic violence.

 

Even in the 24 cases in which courts found domestic violence and granted divorce, the reasoning was sometimes incomplete: four judgments acknowledged domestic violence in their factual findings but granted divorce on the basis of the defendant’s consent, prolonged separation, or a general finding that the marriage had irretrievably broken down. They did not explain what role domestic violence itself played in that decision.

 

2. Unduly narrow standards for finding domestic violence

Of the 1,000 cases, only 29 included an express finding of domestic violence. Over the Law’s first ten years, the average annual finding rate was 2.90%. However, the low rate of domestic violence findings cannot be explained solely by plaintiffs’ failure to prove that the alleged conduct occurred. In some cases, courts characterized violence as a “trivial family matter”; in others, they imposed requirements beyond the statutory definition. Both approaches narrowed the range of conduct that qualifies as domestic violence.

 

Among the 971 cases in which the court did not find domestic violence, 442 (45.5%) were characterized as “trivial family matters.” Courts thus often treated the allegations as ordinary family disputes, suggesting that they viewed the parties as being on equal footing.

 

Even among the 84 cases in which courts expressly found physical violence, courts concluded in 8.33% that the conduct did not constitute domestic violence, characterized the incidents as “trivial family matters” in 32.14%, and did not address the question in a further 28.57%.

 

Even a defendant’s admission did not necessarily lead to a finding of domestic violence. Among the 56 cases in which defendants admitted violence-related facts, courts still characterized the conduct as “trivial family matters” in more than 40% of them.

 

Courts also imposed requirements beyond the statutory definition. At least 19 judgments treated “repetition,” “frequency,” or “long duration” as additional requirements for finding domestic violence, and rejected claims supported by evidence of only a single incident. Other judgments declined to find that the defendant’s violent conduct constituted domestic violence on the ground that the plaintiff was at fault, even though the plaintiff’s fault should not be relevant to that determination.

 

3. Existing rules for assessing evidence are not fully applied in domestic violence cases

The low rate of domestic violence findings is also linked to the incomplete application of existing evidence rules in two respects.

 

First, a defendant’s admission of violence-related facts should relieve the plaintiff of the burden of proving those facts. Yet among the 56 cases in which defendants expressly admitted violent conduct, such as hitting and verbal abuse, 27 judgments neither expressly found that the conduct constituted domestic violence nor found that the defendant had engaged in any form of violence.

 

Second, some courts continued to focus on whether each item of evidence, viewed alone, directly proved the violent act. They paid insufficient attention to how different pieces of evidence corroborated one another. In some sampled judgments, courts did not examine the evidence further simply because the defendant disputed it. Others gave no probative weight to forensic injury assessments because they did not identify the perpetrator, or to police incident records because they did not expressly mention domestic violence.

 

4. Domestic violence is not consistently given effect as a statutory ground for finding irretrievable breakdown

Article 1079 of the PRC Civil Code expressly lists domestic violence as a ground for finding that a marriage has irretrievably broken down. Once domestic violence is established and mediation has failed, the court shall grant divorce. The study found that courts generally granted divorce when they expressly found domestic violence, but not in every case.

 

Divorce was granted in 24 of the 29 cases in which courts expressly found domestic violence, a rate of 82.76%. Yet in the other five, divorce was denied despite the finding. This suggests that plaintiffs may still have to prove irretrievable breakdown separately, even after domestic violence is established.

 

Across the full sample, by contrast, courts granted divorce in only 27.3% of the cases involving domestic violence allegations, with no sustained increase over the decade. The main reasons for denying divorce were insufficient evidence and considerations favoring preservation of the marriage. In only about 2% of cases did courts expressly grant divorce on the basis of domestic violence; most plaintiffs who obtained a divorce did so on other grounds.

 

Divorce was harder still on the first attempt: courts granted divorce in only 14.46% of first-time filings. The estimated probability of obtaining a divorce generally increased with the number of filings. Some plaintiffs in the sample had to file three or even four times to end their marriages, despite having evidence of domestic violence such as police incident records and written pledges by defendants not to repeat the conduct.

 

5. Responses by relevant authorities and organizations do not produce adequate evidence of domestic violence

Police-generated evidence plays a limited role in domestic violence findings. Having a police incident record increased the likelihood of a domestic violence finding by only 5.5 percentage points. This may reflect deficiencies in the records themselves. A review of individual cases showed that some records did not adequately document the caller’s account of domestic violence, the scene, or the police response, and could establish only that a report had been made or that officers had attended the scene. The far smaller number of forensic injury assessments than police incident records also suggests that some police did not promptly help survivors obtain injury assessments after responding to an incident.

 

Evidence from community-level bodies was similarly scarce. Only 10 plaintiffs (3.27% of the cases in which the judgment listed the plaintiff’s evidence) submitted documents issued by residents’ committees, villagers’ committees, or women’s federations. Under the Law, these bodies are required to respond to and assist survivors of domestic violence who seek help. The findings suggest, however, that their performance of these duties is not yet adequately reflected in the evidence available in litigation.

 

Recommendations

1. Set and apply minimum standards for reasoned judgments

The Supreme People’s Court should build on the Rules on Citation of Legal Authorities in Judgments and the Guiding Opinions on Strengthening Reasoning in Judgments to define minimum reasoning requirements for divorce cases involving domestic violence. These requirements should be incorporated into judgment review and judicial training.

 

2. Clarify the standards for judicial findings of domestic violence

The Supreme People’s Court should issue a dedicated judicial interpretation on applying the Anti-Domestic Violence Law, or guidance for adjudicating marriage and family cases involving domestic violence. This should consolidate rules found in existing judicial interpretations and typical cases into consistent standards, supported by training and case quality reviews.

 

3. Develop evidence rules suited to the characteristics of domestic violence

The Supreme People’s Court has stated in typical cases that domestic violence is often covert and occurs in private settings, and that courts should apply evidence rules suited to these characteristics and proactively question the parties and investigate relevant facts. A judicial interpretation of the Anti-Domestic Violence Law or evidence guidance for domestic violence divorce cases should give effect to these principles.

 

4. Standardize police response and the collection and preservation of evidence

The Ministry of Public Security and local public security authorities should focus on implementing and refining the following: (1) unified recording of domestic violence incident reports; (2) standardized evidence-collection procedures; (3) standardized case handling and provision of related materials to courts and survivors; and (4) a risk-assessment and tiered-response mechanism covering all domestic violence incident reports.

 

5. Implement systems for handling complaints, referrals, legal aid, and litigation support

The All-China Women’s Federation and local women’s federations should more fully implement the Trial Rules for Women’s Federations’ Handling of Domestic Violence Complaints. Procuratorates should strengthen implementation of the Guiding Opinions on Several Issues Concerning Procuratorial Support for Civil Lawsuits. Community organizations and women’s federations should follow the Opinions on Strengthening Implementation of the Personal Safety Protection Order System, including the principles of respecting survivors’ wishes, preventing secondary victimization, and providing lawful, timely, and effective protection.

 

6. Give full effect to domestic violence as a statutory ground for divorce

Article 1079 of the Civil Code provides that a court shall grant divorce when domestic violence has occurred and mediation has failed. The Supreme People’s Court should clarify how domestic violence operates as a statutory ground for divorce through judicial interpretations, adjudication guidance, or typical cases, and courts at all levels should apply the rule consistently.